
There’s enough reason to be tense about a meeting of future in laws, or machatunim if we’re being precise, without manslaughter but what’s a dead body between family? Bad Shabbos, a black comedy from Zack Weiner and Daniel Robbins, ups the ante on a religious standoff over family dinner by adding an accidental death that might look like a murder if it was revealed. Nervous guests and family dynamics are pushed to their anxious brink as they individually, then as a group, decide how to handle a stinky corpse hanging out in the powder room.
David (Jon Bass) and Meg (Meghan Leathers) are planning to get married, which requires Meg to begin the process of conversion in order to satisfy Jon and his modern religious family. In order to smooth the transition, they’ve invited Meg’s parents to Friday night dinner at David’s parents’ place so everyone can meet and her parents can get a sense of the tradition. Tensions are already high with Jon’s mother (Kyra Sedgwick) being less than accepting of Meg, Jon’s brother, Adam (Theo Taplitz), being a medicated foil to social situations, and Jon’s sister, Abby (Milana Vayntrub), sparring with her partner, Ben (Ashley Zukerman) who doesn’t seem to get along with anyone. After Ben clashes with Adam, Adam cooks up a scheme to dose him with his prescription laxative. But Adam somehow doesn’t know about Ben’s congenital digestive issues, and the cocktail of medication and dairy products knocks Ben off his balance and into the bathroom fixtures. Discovering his dead body, the siblings decide to protect Adam by covering it up and then are forced to do so during a hectic dinner where dynamics and relationships are already being tested.
The sprawling apartment, the countdown until Meg’s parents’ door knock, and a helpful doorman (Method Man), will all keep the bickering family on their toes as they navigate how to handle the tell-tale heart no longer beating in their powder room. That’s what creates the tension and allows for the comedy to spill over and into the New York City high rise.
Bad Shabbos wants us to laugh until we maybe toot and it’s mostly successful. Panicking family members and the comedic chops of people like Vayntrub and Method Man make for the tense kinds of laughs you want in this single location bruhaha. It’s not quite Clue or an Agatha Christie story, but it doesn’t seem to be trying to be more than a good old cluster of calamities where everyone is in on information at different times. It’s a less bloody version of a movie like Happy Times (2019), which sits closer to “comedy” on the “black comedy” spectrum making it easier to recommend to your extended family.
While there are certainly laughs to be had, much of Bad Shabbos relies on some outdated Jewish jokes and tropes about Jewish mothers it might be time to move on from. Jokes about the banks, the media, and unaccepting mothers are tired, but perhaps Bad Shabbos is taking ownership of them or exploring a personal experience that I can’t invalidate.
Bad Shabbos is an imperfect single location black comedy but one I am so happy exists. Clashing cultures, relationship and family dynamics, and tight dinner quarters are always ripe for solid explorations and gags, but chucking in a dead guy and an implicated murderer ups every version of that ante. For those looking for a harmless laugh, especially one about their own culture or similar experience with one, Bad Shabbos is a little delight, and a bit of a love note to the Jews of NY.
Bad Shabbos opens in NYC May 23, 2025 and LA and select cities on June 6, 2025
